“Welcome to the party.” I can only take that as admission that, yes, extinguishing democracy is okay as long as your party finishes on top.
I have a feeling that you haven’t been watching all these hearings, just the spin around them from whatever info terrain you’re plugged into. Or am I wrong? Have you watched all three hearings, or just editorials about them?
There is no plausible deniability left here. It’s all been stripped away. It has been proven that Trump was well informed from every angle that the claims of election fraud were false, and only the crackpots were still telling him they were true. And every case ended up getting thrown out of court, and many lawyers disbarred, because the claims were so egregiously false. So your premise that Trump had any room to rationally doubt the election outcomes is provably false. And even the crackpots that remained around Trump after “team normal” was given the boot, knew that the claims were bunk, as were the legal grounds for their plan to have Pence overthrow the election results for Trump. Eastman even said he knew the Supreme Court would vote against him “9-0”, before preemptively asking for a pardon from Trump for crimes that he therefore knew he committed.
It was a deeply cynical, corrupt, illegal, and wholly un-American attempt to hijack and, by effect, extinguish our democracy.
Really, what you are saying only reinforces my concern that today’s GOP is primarily driven by three things: nihilism (the Constitution doesn’t actually matter, despite lip service), opportunism (the only thing that matters is winning more power), and narcissism (Trump and his personality cult).
What’s really interesting to me, is this is very clearly showing a rupture that runs through the center of the GOP as a party. These are Republicans testifying against Republicans, after all. Today’s hearing was basically a three hour celebration of Mike Pence. They are giving Republican voters like you an opportunity to actually take in all the objective, undeniable evidence, to rethink their continued allegiance to Trump (or at least unwillingness to admit his blatant malfeasance), to admit how malignant he and his crimes are, and to realign themselves with the white hat Republicans (such as Pence and many of the witnesses), all without feeling like they would abandoning their party. But, alas, the opportunity hardly seems to be getting through, because as you mention above, the people who need to see this won’t be watching. If they did, the cognitive dissonance would simply be too much.
Instead they are getting rid of Cheney, for the simple reason that she is one of the only courageous people left in the GOP willing to criticize and hold Trump accountable for his crimes. There’s literally no other reason. Today’s GOP knows they absolutely cannot lose Trump’s supporters if they hope to win elections, so the only option is tune their political and media machines to the noise of total nihilism. The Constitution doesn’t actually matter, regardless of what we say, all that matters is maintaining power.
Here’s my personal integral analysis, as of this moment. Consider it a rough draft of personal reflections.
I think what Trump did — and what the GOP did and has done to cover for him — is blatantly, objectively, and profanely wrong. It was undemocratic, illegal, and in violation of both the letter and the spirit of the Constitution. I believe this is self-evidently true for all healthy altitudes from amber to turquoise, and believe the majority of Trump supporters at those altitudes would likely experience a great amount of cognitive dissonance while watching these hearings, having their plausible deniability stripped away, and continuing their support. And I believe that bringing these crimes into the light and holding the criminals accountable is far, far more important than any popularity polls, or any person’s political career.
Here’s what’s alive for me. It’s looking mostly at values and worldview. Of course this is a very rough sketch, and people are far more complex than this.
Magenta: whatever my clan thinks.
Red: Narcissism and conspiracy theories (a product of narcissism). Trump was right to do this. Might makes right. Fuck the libtards. Personality cults (such as Qanon) are a hallmark of the red altitude, now and throughout history.
Unhealthy amber: Party and ideology over country. We hate the left more than we love the country — which means that the ends therefore justify the means, especially in war. We may believe the election really was stolen, despite having no objective evidence, or we might just pretend to believe, so we don’t risk losing power and public support. “If conservatives become convinced that they cannot win democratically, they will not abandon conservatism, they will abandon democracy.” -David Frum ®
Healthy amber: This is profane, unethical, and clearly violates the most sacred core intentions of the Founders and the God-given Constitution they delivered to and for the world. All criminals should be prosecuted to the full extent of the law.
Unhealthy orange: It’s only ever about winning. Optics are more important than ethics. How can I spin or deflect this so I and/or my team can profit, either materially, politically, or personally?
Healthy Orange: The evidence clearly demonstrates that this was an objective violation of both the letter and the spirit of the Constitutional process, one of the most self-evidently rational systems of governance the world has ever produced, and founded on the very principle of the peaceful transfer of power. Allowing this to go unpunished drives a stake in the heart of our democracy, and will only ensure it happens again.
Unhealthy green: This was obviously illegal, but it doesn’t matter, nothing will happen. Power structures are such that no one will ever be held accountable. Nothing matters, we’re fucked.
Healthy green: This was obviously and blatantly immoral and illegal, and is demonstrative of how oligarchic power structures continue to roll over the people and even the rule of law. Hard-won rights and civil protections are now seriously at risk. We need to rise up, protest, and take back our democracy from the nihilists, opportunists, and narcissists who are actively trying to destroy it.
Teal: I agree with all those healthy versions of myself below, and can feel all those responses within me. This is yet another example of how life conditions are arranging themselves in ways that only integral approaches can resolve. Every stage of development is on fire, and pushing away from every other stage, and it is causing the entire spiral — and the structures that support it — to collapse on itself. The world is burning, and everything is perfect. Everything is right on schedule, and things will continue to get better, even while they will likely become worse. But evolution can only happen through us, not outside or around us, which means that I need to meditate, eat my veggies, show up as fully and impactfully as I can within my own sphere of influence, and find the opportunities and leverage points to help the human spiral pull itself back together.